I've been trying out the Loreal Colour Caress Wet Shine in Rose On and On for a while no. I've heard really mixed reviews. Most negative reviews complain about the lasting time or that it doesn't stain as well as other stains. Loreal claims it will leave your lips soft, comfortable, and hydrated for up to 6 hours. I think it does just that for about 3 hours. I think that the color is gorgeous, I like that it doesn't stain too much, and I like that it doesn't make my lips feel dry like some stains do. I think a lot of people get hung up on how long it will stay on your lips, but I always keep my expectations low. Maybe that's why I don't get disappointed. Overall, I really like this product, and will more than likely pick up a couple more colors.